Miller Reserve Penny Loafer
The Recraftable Guarantee
Handcrafted with our legendary 360º Goodyear Bench Welt. When the soles or heels wear down, return your shoes to our Wisconsin artisans to be resoled, re-corked, and restored to like-new condition.
Discover Recrafting Services →Product Details
The highest quality shoes we've ever made. Handcrafted from the ground up by our artisans in Port Washington, Wisconsin. Each design in the Reserve collection is based on our archives with robust proportions that define classic American shoemaking. Only the very best materials used at each stage of the process.
STYLE- DESIGN: Slip-on penny loafer
- STYLING: Traditional detailing like pinking on the tongue and wheeling on the welt
- FIT: Classic, take your regular size
- EXTENDED SIZES: Offered in a full range of options from 7 to 15
- EXTENDED WIDTHS: Narrow B, standard D or wide E options
- Black Maremma crust calfskin made with the best Dutch hides that are treated in Italy for a glossy polish
- Walnut, Dark Brown or Natural Ilcea Betis crust calfskin sourced from the finest European hides that are hand finished in Italy for an incredibly rich polish
- Burgundy shell Cordovan from Horween tannery in Chicago, famed for its durability and lustrous surface
- Black or Dark Brown genuine crocodile with hand-antiqued finish
- CONSTRUCTION: Goodyear welt construction for durability
- INTERIOR: Semi-aniline Italian leather lining
- SOLES: Double-layer, Italian vegetable-tanned leather outsoles that are hand painted. Walnut color features Lactae Hevea soles made from flexible crepe latex derived from hevea trees.
- HEELS: Leather top lifts with dovetail heel strikes secured with brass nails
- SUPPORT: CustomCork™ insoles
- ARTISANSHIP: Handcrafted in Port Washington, Wisconsin with imported materials
- RECRAFTING: Can be recrafted by our experts in Port Washington
- SHAPE: Built on the 2041 footwear last with a substantial profile and round toe shape
STYLE
- DESIGN: Venetian slip-on loafer combining dress polish with sneaker-like versatility
- STYLING: Pairs effortlessly with tailored trousers, relaxed chinos, or premium denim
- FIT: Classic, take your regular size
- EXTENDED SIZES: Offered in a full range of sizes from 7 to 15
- EXTENDED WIDTHS: Available in Narrow B, Standard D, Wide E, and Extra Wide 3E
FUNCTION
- CONSTRUCTION: 360º Goodyear Bench Welt construction for unparalleled lateral stability and lifetime durability
- INTERIOR: Glove-tanned calfskin leather lining ensures breathable, seamless comfort against the foot
- SUPPORT: CustomCork™ footbed molds to the unique contours of your foot
- SOLES: Flexible lightweight hybrid sole with all-weather traction pods
CRAFT
- ARTISANSHIP: Handcrafted in Port Washington, Wisconsin with ultra-premium imported leathers and suede
- RECRAFTING: Can be recrafted and renewed by our Wisconsin workshop artisans
- MATERIALS: Hand-burnished European full-grain leather that develops rich patina over time
- SHAPE: Built on our celebrated footwear lasts for enduring support
Fit & Sizing Guide
Handcrafted on Allen Edmonds' iconic 65 Last, our most celebrated and versatile silhouette.
- Profile: Features an elongated, classic almond cap-toe profile with a sleek cone and snug, supportive heel cup.
- Multi-Width Guarantee: Available in 4 specialized widths: Narrow (B), Medium (D), Wide (E), and Extra Wide (3E).
- Sizing Advice: Fits true to standard Brannock size. Because Goodyear-welted leather molds to your foot, an initial snug fit over the instep will break in smoothly within 3 to 5 wearings.
Care & Recrafting
Your Allen Edmonds are built to last a lifetime with proper care and routine refurbishment.
- Routine Care: Wipe clean with a damp cloth after wear. Apply Allen Edmonds Leather Lotion monthly and finish with matching shoe cream to nourish the leather and preserve depth of color.
- Shoe Trees: Insert cedar shoe trees immediately after each wearing to absorb moisture and maintain the original shape.
- Factory Recrafting Service: When your soles or heels wear down, send your shoes directly to our Port Washington workshop where master artisans will disassemble, resole, re-cork, and refinish the uppers to like-new condition.
Shipping & Free Returns
We stand firmly behind the quality and craftsmanship of our footwear with worry-free fulfillment policies.
- Complimentary Shipping: Free standard ground shipping on domestic US orders over $100 (delivers in 3-5 business days). Expedited 2-day and overnight services are available at checkout.
- Free 30-Day Returns: Unworn, undamaged shoes in original packaging can be returned or exchanged within 30 days of delivery. Free prepaid return labels are included with domestic orders.
- Store Pickup: Free in-store pickup available at Allen Edmonds retail locations and Port Washington studio.
Our Craftsmanship Guarantee
Every pair of shoes that leaves our Port Washington, Wisconsin factory carries our unwavering promise of enduring American quality.
- Over a Century of Heritage: Handcrafting premium men's dress footwear in Wisconsin since 1922.
- 212 Individual Steps: Hand-cut, hand-lasted, and welted by skilled artisans who take pride in their timeless trade.
- Built to be Rebuilt: True Goodyear welt construction ensures your shoes can be renewed repeatedly for decades of distinguished wear.
Customer Reviews (148)
Unmatched craftsmanship and comfort
“This is my third pair of Allen Edmonds and they continue to exceed expectations. The leather quality is magnificent and having true width options (E for me) means no painful break-in period. Knowing they can be recrafted down the road makes them the smartest investment in my wardrobe.”
Timeless classic that gets better with age
“Superb construction, handsome finish, and fantastic arch support thanks to the cork insole. The 360-degree welt gives it that substantial American silhouette you just can’t find anywhere else.”
Similar Styles
Customers Also Bought
The Art of American Shoemaking
Every pair undergoes 212 meticulous steps, uniting century-old bench welt techniques with supreme orthopedic comfort and lifetime durability.
360º Goodyear Bench Welt
A continuous ribbon of premium leather is stitched around the full 360-degree perimeter of the shoe. This creates a water-resistant seal, ultimate lateral stability, and allows the shoe to be completely resoled repeatedly.
212-Step AssemblyCustomCork™ Insole System
Beneath the leather footbed rests a generous bed of natural cork. As you walk, warmth and pressure mold the cork to the exact imprint of your foot, creating bespoke orthopedic arch support that improves every time you wear them.
Self-Conforming FitPort Washington Recrafting
Our shoes aren't meant for a season—they are built for decades. Whenever your soles wear down, send them home to our Wisconsin workshop to be stripped, rebuilt with brand new welts and soles, and returned good as new.
Explore Recrafting Services →